In this study we used TEPITOPE, a new epitope prediction software, to identify sequence segments on the MAGE-3 protein with promiscuous binding to histocompatibility leukocyte antigen (HLA)-DR molecules. Synthetic peptides corresponding to the identified sequences were synthesized and used to propagate CD4+ T cells from the blood of a healthy donor. CD4+ T cells strongly recognized MAGE-3281–295 and, to a lesser extent, MAGE-3141–155 and MAGE-3146–160. Moreover, CD4+ T cells proliferated in the presence of recombinant MAGE-3 after processing and presentation by autologous antigen presenting cells, demonstrating that the MAGE-3 epitopes recognized are naturally processed. CD4+ T cells, mostly of the T helper 1 type, showed specific lytic activity against HLA-DR11/MAGE-3–positive melanoma cells. Cold target inhibition experiments demonstrated indeed that the CD4+ T cells recognized MAGE-3281–295 in association with HLA-DR11 on melanoma cells. This is the first evidence that a tumor-specific shared antigen forms CD4+ T cell epitopes. Furthermore, we validated the use of algorithms for the prediction of promiscuous CD4+ T cell epitopes, thus opening the possibility of wide application to other tumor-associated antigens. These results have direct implications for cancer immunotherapy in the design of peptide-based vaccines with tumor-specific CD4+ T cell epitopes.
The importance of CD4+ T lymphocytes in antitumor immunity has been clearly demonstrated in animal models. CD4+ T cells exert helper activity for the induction and maintenance of antitumor CD8+ T cells (1–7), but they may also have an effector function either by indirect mechanism against MHC class II–negative tumors, via macrophages activation (for a review, see reference 1), or by direct mechanism against MHC class II–positive tumors (6, 7).
Recently, the requirement of cognate CD4+ T cell help for optimal induction of antitumor CD8+ CTLs was demonstrated (8). Vaccination with a specific viral T helper epitope, but not with an unrelated T helper epitope, resulted in protective immunity against MHC class II–negative, virus-induced tumor cells. Moreover, simultaneous vaccination with the tumor-specific T helper and CTL epitopes resulted in strong synergistic protection.
In humans, evidence for a role of CD4+ T cells in antitumor immunity comes from the study of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes, which revealed the presence of both CD8+ and CD4+ T cells at the tumor site (9, 10), and from detection in the sera of neoplastic patients of antibodies directed against tumor antigens (for a review, see reference 11). However, in recent years research on T cell immunity against human tumors has focused mainly on identification of CD8+ HLA class I–restricted CTL responses. To date tyrosinase, a tissue-specific antigen expressed in normal and neoplastic cells of melanocytic lineage, is the only melanoma-associated antigen demonstrated as a specific target for CD4+ melanoma-reactive T cells (12, 13) and for which CD4+ T cell epitopes have been identified (14).
Characterization of the CD4+ T cell epitope repertoire on other tumor-associated antigens, especially those that are tumor-specific and shared among tumors of several histotypes (for a review, see reference 15), would contribute decisively to improve the efficacy of peptide-based immunization protocols in neoplastic patients.
MAGE-3 is a tumor-specific antigen encoded by a gene expressed in a high proportion of melanomas and in several other tumor histotypes (head and neck squamous cell carcinomas, bladder carcinomas, lung carcinomas and sarcomas) and not in normal tissues, with the exception of testis and placenta (for a review, see reference 15). CD8+ CTLs from melanoma patients recognize HLA class I–restricted MAGE-3 epitopes (15), and clinical trials with synthetic peptides corresponding to HLA-A1 and/or -A2 MAGE-3 binding sequences are ongoing in patients affected by melanoma and other neoplastic diseases (15). Therefore, MAGE-3 is an excellent candidate protein to study the antitumor CD4+ T cell response. This protein has an intracytoplasmic localization (16), making its presentation on MHC class II molecules unlikely or difficult. However, it has been clearly shown that the MHC class II pathway can present endogenous cellular peptides (17–19), and peptides eluted from purified HLA-DR molecules of the melanoma cell line FM3 contained peptides derived from processing of cytoplasmic proteins (20).
In this study, we used a new T cell epitope prediction software (TEPITOPE; reference 21, and our manuscript in preparation) to identify MAGE-3 sequences with promiscuous HLA-DR binding characteristics. Synthetic peptides corresponding to five identified sequences were used to propagate CD4+ T cells from the blood of a healthy donor. We show that CD4+ T cells are MAGE-3 specific and recognize naturally processed sequence segment(s). Moreover, CD4+ T cells are cytolytic and recognize MAGE-3281–295 in association with HLA-DR11 on melanoma cells.
Materials And Methods
T Cell Epitope Prediction.
TEPITOPE, a new T cell epitope prediction software, is a Windows™ application that enables the identification of (a) class II ligands binding in a promiscuous or allele-specific mode, and (b) the effects of polymorphic residues on class II ligand specificity (21, and our manuscript in preparation). 25 quantitative matrix-based HLA-DR motifs, covering the majority of class II ligand specificity, are incorporated in TEPITOPE (22, and our manuscript in preparation) and provide the basis for various algorithms included in the software package. Starting from any protein sequence, the algorithm permits the prediction and parallel display of ligands for each of the 25 HLA-DR alleles. To predict MAGE-3 CD4+ T cell epitopes, we loaded the protein sequence into the software looking for promiscuous peptide regions. We set the TEPITOPE prediction threshold at 5% (21) and picked peptide sequences predicted to bind at least 50% of the HLA-DR molecules incorporated in the software.
DR–Peptide Binding Assay.
Peptide interactions with detergent-solubilized DR molecules were measured using an ELISA-based high-flux competition assay (23). HLA-DR molecules were isolated from the following human lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL): DR1 (DRB1*0101) from HOM-2, DR3 (DRB1*0301) from WT49, DR4 (DRB1*0401) from PREISS, DR5 (DRB1* 1101) from SWEIG, DR7 (DRB1*0701) from EKR, and DR8 (DRB1*0801) from BM9. DR2 (DRB1*1501) was isolated from the L cell transfectant L466.1. The molecules were affinity purified using the mAb 1-1C4 (24) as described (25). Peptide competition assays were conducted to measure the ability of unlabeled peptides to compete with a biotinylated indicator peptide for binding to purified DR molecules. The following biotinylated indicator peptides were used: GFKA7 for DR1 and DR7; GIRA2YA4 for DR2; LAYDA5 for DR3; UD4 for DR4 (26); TT 830–843 for DR5; and GYRA6L for DR8. The biotinylated indicator peptide and HLA-DR molecules were incubated with 10-fold dilutions (0.001–100 mM) of the unlabeled competitor peptides (peptides corresponding to the MAGE-3 predicted sequences). To determine relative peptide binding affinity, the promiscuous HA307–319 peptide from influenza hemagglutinin (27) was included in each competition assay. The relative binding data of the unlabeled competitor peptides were expressed as inhibitory concentration (IC50), i.e., the concentration of competitor peptide required to inhibit 50% of binding of the biotinylated indicator peptide.
Synthetic peptides corresponding to MAGE-3141–155, MAGE-3146–160, MAGE-3156–170, MAGE-3171–185, and MAGE-3281–295 sequences were manufactured on a 9050 Millipore synthesizer. The purity of the peptides was evaluated by reverse-phase HPLC and electron spray mass spectrometry. Synthetic peptides were lyophilized and then reconstituted in DMSO at 2 mg/ml concentration and diluted in PBS as needed.
Cloning and Expression of rMAGE-3.
Full-length MAGE-3 coding sequences were inserted into expression vector pET16b (Novagen), allowing the production of the NH2 terminus 10-histidine tail as described (16). Production and purification of the recombinant fusion protein on nickel column were monitored by SDS-PAGE and Coomassie blue staining.
Propagation of CD4+ T Cells.
The five synthetic peptides corresponding to the MAGE-3 sequences most promiscuous for HLA-DR binding (see Table I) were pooled (hereafter MAGE-3 pool) and used to stimulate the PBMCs of a healthy donor whose HLA type, identified by standard serologic typing, is A1, A2/ B41, B52/DR11, as described (28). In brief, 20 × 106 PBMCs were cultivated for 7 d in RPMI 1640 (GIBCO BRL) supplemented with 10% heat-inactivated human serum (Technogenetics), 2 mM l-glutamine, 100 U/ml penicillin, 50 μg/ml streptomycin (Biowhittaker) (TCM) containing the MAGE-3 pool (1 μg/ml of each peptide). The reactive lymphoblasts were isolated on a Percoll gradient (28), further expanded in T cell growth factor (Lymphocult; Biotest Diagnostic Inc.), and restimulated at weekly intervals with the same amount of antigen plus irradiated (4,000 rad) autologous PBMCs as APCs.
Cytofluorimetric analyses were performed on a FACStarPlus® (Becton Dickinson). The following mAbs were used: anti-CD4–PE and anti-CD8–FITC (Becton Dickinson), D1.12 (purified from an anti-MHC class II hybridoma supernatant), and 57B (described in reference 16). FITC-rabbit anti–mouse Ig antibody (DAKO) was used as second-step reagent in indirect immunofluorescence stainings. Staining for intracytoplasmic MAGE-3 expression was performed as described (29). Intracytoplasmic staining for cytokine expression was performed using the anti–INF-γ and anti–IL-4 mAbs, following the manufacturer's instructions (Sigma).
CD4+ T cells and autologous irradiated PBMCs were diluted in TCM to 2 × 105/ml and 2 × 106/ml, respectively, and plated in triplicate in 96 round-bottomed well plates (100 μl of CD4+ T cells and 100 μl of APCs). The cells were stimulated with different concentrations of MAGE-3 pool (0.05, 0.1, 0.5, 1, and 5 μg/ml), each peptide (10 μg/ml), and different concentrations of rMAGE-3 protein (5, 10, and 20 μg/ ml). Triplicate wells with CD4+ T cells alone and APCs alone were used as controls. Three wells with CD4+ T cells plus APCs did not receive any stimulus in order to determine the basal growth rate (the blank). In inhibition experiments, different concentrations of mAb L243 or an isotype-matched irrelevant mAb (0.25 and 0.5 mg/ml) were added in triplicate wells of CD4+ cells plus APCs stimulated with MAGE-3 pool (5 μg/ml) or MAGE-3281–295 (10 μg/ml). After 3 d, the cultures were pulsed for 16 h with [3H]TdR (1 mCi/well, 6.7 Ci/mol; Amersham Pharmacia Biotech). The cells were collected with a Titertek multiple harvester (Skatron, Inc.), and the thymidine incorporated was measured in a liquid scintillation counter. The percentage of inhibition was calculated as follows: [(cpm without mAb − cpm with mAb)/(cpm without mAb)] × 100.
CD4+ T cells were tested for specific lytic activity in a standard 4-h 51Cr-release assay as described (30). The following targets were used: melanoma cells (SK-Mel 28, HT144, OI TC described in reference 29, and MD TC established in our laboratory from a cutaneous metastasis), and LCL. The HLA-DR type of target cells, identified by molecular or serologic typing, was SK-Mel 28 (DR*04*13), HT144 (DR*04*07), OI TC (DR*01*11), MD TC (DR*04*11), LCL (DR11). In cold target competition assays, unlabeled target cells (cold targets) were seeded in plates at serial ratios of hot-to-cold target cells. Effector CD4+ T cells and 51Cr-labeled target cells (hot targets) were then added, and cytotoxicity was assessed as described above. Percentage inhibition was calculated as follows: [(% specific lysis without cold target − % specific lysis with cold target)/(% specific lysis without cold target)] × 100.
Results And Discussion
10 synthetic peptides corresponding to sequence segments predicted by TEPITOPE to form promiscuous MAGE-3 CD4+ T cell epitopes were synthesized, and their binding to purified molecules of 7 widely diffuse HLA-DR alleles was verified. Based on the results of the competition binding assays, 5 (i.e., the sequences with the greatest degree of promiscuity) of the 10 predicted sequences were chosen for further experiments (Table I). The five synthetic peptides were pooled (MAGE-3 pool) and used to stimulate the PBMCs of a healthy donor. T cells were 94% CD4+ after 1 wk of culture (not shown), and could be propagated in long-term culture by weekly restimulation with the MAGE-3 pool in the presence of autologous irradiated PBMCs. Reactivity of CD4+ T cells was tested in microproliferation assays (Fig. 1): the cells responded vigorously to the MAGE-3 pool (Fig. 1 A), even at low concentrations (100–500 ng/ml). Reactivity to the individual peptides forming the pool was also periodically investigated (Fig. 1 C): the CD4+ T cells recognized predominantly the peptide corresponding to MAGE-3281–295 and, although to a much lower but significant extent, the peptides corresponding to the overlapping sequences MAGE-3141–155 and MAGE-3146–160. All three sequences recognized by the CD4+ T cells showed a high binding affinity to purified DR11 molecules (see Table I). Reactivity to MAGE-3281–295 increased during the propagation of the line (Fig. 1 C). The proliferative activity of CD4+ T cells in the presence of MAGE-3 pool (Fig. 1 D, a) or MAGE-3281–295 (Fig. 1 D, b) was inhibited by addition in culture of different concentrations of L243 mAb (Fig. 1 D), demonstrating that the recognition of MAGE-3 sequences was HLA-DR restricted. We next tested the CD4+ T cells for cross-reactivity with the native protein (Fig. 1 B). CD4+ T cells strongly recognized the rMAGE-3 protein after processing and presentation by autologous APCs, demonstrating that the synthetic sequences recognized by the CD4+ T cells indeed formed naturally processed epitopes.
Intracytoplasmic staining for IL-4 and INF-γ expression, performed after CD4+ T cell activation with PMA and ionomycin, revealed that 70% of the CD4+ T cells produced INF-γ while no cells produced IL-4 (data not shown), suggesting that they belong mostly to the Th1 type.
To characterize the functional activity of the MAGE-3– specific CD4+ T cells, we tested their killing potential against melanoma cells expressing the MAGE-3 protein and the HLA-DR molecules (Fig. 2 B). CD4+ T cells showed cytolytic activity against OI TC and MD TC, which express the HLA-DR11 restricting allele, whereas they did not kill SK-Mel 28 and HT144, which express unrelated HLA-DR alleles (Fig. 2 A). To verify whether the cytolytic CD4+ T cells recognized HLA-DR11– restricted MAGE-3 epitopes on melanoma cells, we first tested their lytic activity against HLA-DR11+ LCL unpulsed, or pulsed with the synthetic peptides recognized in microproliferation assays. LCL pulsed with MAGE-3281–295 were strongly recognized by the CD4+ T cells, whereas no killing activity against LCL unpulsed or pulsed with MAGE-3141–155 and MAGE-3146–160 was detectable (Fig. 3 A). Second, we performed cold target inhibition experiments which showed that the lytic activity of CD4+ T cells against OI TC was inhibited by the addition of LCL pulsed with MAGE-3281–295 (Fig. 3 B), demonstrating that this sequence is indeed presented by HLA-DR11 on the OI TC melanoma cells. These results further demonstrate that MAGE-3281–295 is naturally processed and forms a cytotoxic CD4+ T cell epitope. Since the polyclonal CD4+ T cells proliferated in the presence of the rMAGE-3 protein, and in addition to MAGE-3281–295 they also recognized MAGE-3141–155 and MAGE-3146–160, we cannot exclude that these last two sequences may also yield natural epitopes, which are recognized by CD4+ T cells with functional activity different from killing. Moreover, although CD4+ T cells were mostly Th1 and had direct effector function upon tumor recognition, we cannot exclude that in vivo such CD4+ T cells could also exert a helper activity in the induction phase of the immune response.
One approach for identifying CD4+ T cell epitopes on a candidate protein is the use of overlapping synthetic peptides corresponding to the complete sequence of the protein. The major drawback of this approach is the number of peptide sequences that need to be tested, thus making this approach too expensive and time consuming. In this study, we used the TEPITOPE software package to computationally identify promiscuous HLA-DR binding sites starting from primary protein structures. We demonstrated that TEPITOPE predicted sequence segments capable of binding to multiple HLA-DR alleles. Furthermore, we showed that one or more of the predicted HLA-DR ligands were indeed naturally processed, thus confirming the validity of this approach. We expect that the application of TEPITOPE to other tumor-associated antigens will speed up identification of the antitumor CD4+ T cell epitope repertoire in humans.
Clinical trials based on the use of melanocyte-specific antigens (such as gp100, MART-1/Melan-A, and tyrosinase, for which CD4+ T cell epitopes were identified) are in progress in melanoma patients, and although no significant side effects were reported in a recent study that used a gp100 peptide for the treatment of HLA-A2+ patients (31), the development of autoimmune responses against normal tissue must be considered when using self-differentiation antigens as vaccines. The demonstration that MAGE-3 (i.e., an antigen not expressed in normal tissues, with the exception of testis and placenta, which are unlikely to be targets of T cells since they do not express MHC molecules), can form CD4+ T cell epitopes further supports its use for vaccination protocols in neoplastic patients using a mixture of synthetic peptides corresponding to CD8+ and CD4+ T cell epitopes.
Previous findings (13, 32, 33) reported a lytic activity of melanoma-specific CD4+ T cells. Here we give the molecular definition of an epitope able to stimulate cytolytic CD4+ T cells that can be grown in vitro with ease, raising the possibility of using those CD4+ T cells in protocols of adoptive transfer in neoplastic patients whose neoplasm expresses the MAGE-3 protein and the MHC class II molecules.
In conclusion, in this study we identified the first CD4+ T cell epitope on a tumor-specific antigen, and we verified that the approach used here to predict promiscuous CD4+ T cell epitopes yielded natural epitopes. It will be important to evaluate whether the identified CD4+ T cell epitopes are indeed promiscuous, making their use for peptide-based vaccines less allele dependent and more widely applicable.
We thank Giuseppe Consogno for excellent technical support and Catia Traversari for critical reading of the manuscript and helpful discussions.
This work was supported by the Fondazione Centro San Raffaele del Monte Tabor, the Italian Association for Cancer Research (AIRC), the Ministry of University and Scientific Research (MURST), and the Swiss National Fund.
Address correspondence to Maria Pia Protti, Laboratory of Tumor Immunology, Scientific Institute H. San Raffaele, Via Olgettina 60, 20132 Milan, Italy. Phone: 39-2-2643-2612; Fax: 39-2-2643-2611; E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org